As the Minnesota Golf Association (MGA) evolved over its 100+ year history, they’ve consistently adapted to the changing landscape of amateur golf and the opportunity to increase the number of participants in the state of Minnesota. Known for having among the most golfers per capita in the country, the MGA found itself ready to unite behind the vision of the United States Golf Association (USGA) and expand its focus to increase the number of recreational golfers in the state with a USGA GHIN (Golf Handicap Information Network) handicap.
While the vision was clear, separating itself as an organization from legacy infrastructure and processes proved to be the real challenge. The organization faced significant operational challenges due to their reliance on an outdated, custom-developed, proprietary Customer Relationship Management (CRM) and Content Management System (CMS) with multiple disconnected platforms. Per the recommendation of the USGA, the MGA decided to transition to HubSpot's integrated platform. By leveraging the power of HubSpot’s CMS, CRM and Marketing Automation platform, the MGA streamlined operations, enhanced member engagement, improved donation management, and accrued substantial cost savings through platform consolidation. This case study details the MGA’s transformational journey and highlights the key benefits realized, creating a blueprint for other Allied Golf Associations (AGAs) looking to modernize their technological infrastructure.
Background
As one of 56 Allied Golf Associations operating under the United States Golf Association, the MGA serves Minnesota's golf community through membership services, tournament operations, handicap administration, course ratings, and charitable foundation activities. Prior to working with StoryTeller, their legacy technology ecosystem consisted of:
-
Proprietary CRM/CMS system
-
NeonCRM for donation management
-
AFS Payment Platform for payment processing
-
Campaigner Email Marketing Platform for email campaigns
-
Custom-developed API Integrations with GHIN, Golf Genius, NeonCRM and AFS
Although integrations existed, the technology stack was still fragmented, creating workflow inefficiencies, data silos, and limited reporting capabilities while requiring significant ongoing development and maintenance costs.
FREE DOWNLOAD
How about a copy to-go?
Just fill out this quick form and read the case study when it's convenient for you.
Challenges and Solutions
Challenge 1: Website Management Constraints
Challenge: The MGA operated an outdated, custom-developed website that required developer intervention for even minor updates. This created bottlenecks in communication, increased costs for routine changes, and limited the team's ability to respond quickly to member needs.
Solution: Complete website redesign and development using HubSpot Content Hub Professional, employing a flexible theme structure with customized templates.
Benefits: Improved website management through empowered staff, faster updates, enhanced user experience, integrated analytics, seamless CRM data connection, rapid landing page deployment, streamlined content creation, reduced maintenance costs, and improved SEO and mobile responsiveness.
Challenge 2: GHIN Integration Limitations
Challenge: The MGA had invested in custom development to integrate their proprietary system with GHIN, creating a maintenance burden and potential point of failure.
Solution: Implementation of the USGA-developed GHIN to HubSpot integration.
Benefits: Real-time member data synchronization, a comprehensive data model, automated workflows, enhanced segmentation, creation of custom objects for relationship tracking, reduced integration maintenance costs, improved data accuracy and reliability, and enhanced ability to identify at-risk members.
Challenge 3: Email Marketing Inefficiencies
Challenge: MGA utilized Campaigner as a standalone email marketing platform, necessitating manual data imports/exports and limiting personalization capabilities.
Solution: Consolidated email marketing operations within HubSpot Marketing Hub Professional, leveraging native CRM data for enhanced segmentation and automation.
Benefits: Leveraging HubSpot Marketing Hub Professional resulted in cost savings, reduced data management time, improved communication targeting and personalization, enhanced deliverability and engagement, implementation of automation, better performance tracking, and optimized communication strategies with dynamic content delivery.
Challenge 4: Tournament Management Complexities
Challenge: MGA's custom integration with Golf Genius tournament software required ongoing maintenance and offered limited visibility into participation data.
Solution: Implementation of the official Golf Genius to HubSpot integration, providing seamless data flow between tournament operations and member profiles.
Benefits: Synchronization of tournament data, improved communication strategies, enhanced tournament promotion, consolidated data views, automated workflows, streamlined reporting, reduced overhead, improved data correlation, and enhanced member experience.
Challenge 5: Member Support Management
Challenge: The MGA lacked a structured system for tracking and resolving member inquiries, relying on email forwards and manual follow-ups without accountability mechanisms or performance metrics.
Solution: Implementation of HubSpot Service Hub Professional with ticket management system, knowledge base capabilities, and automated support workflows.
Benefits: Improved member support management through centralized tracking, improved response times, enhanced accountability, development of a knowledge base, identification of support themes, integration of satisfaction surveys, creation of performance dashboards, cost savings, enhanced member satisfaction, and data-driven process improvement.
Challenge 6: Golf Course Record Management
Challenge: MGA needed to maintain Golf Courses as distinct entities separate from Golf Clubs, with appropriate relationships to clubs and personnel.
Solution: Development of a custom Golf Course solution in HubSpot with defined relationships to Clubs and Staff.
Benefits: A comprehensive digital inventory of golf courses, improved data tracking and reporting, streamlined communications, enhanced course rating administration, improved data segmentation, an enhanced data model, simplified relationship management, and improved data governance.
Challenge 7: Donation Management Fragmentation
Challenge: MGA's donation process was fragmented across NeonCRM, AFS payment processing, and their proprietary system, resulting in broken recurring donations and limited donor insight.
Solution: Consolidated donation management using HubSpot Deals and Payments, which are part of the HubSpot Sales Hub, for online processing, with comprehensive import of historical donation data.
Benefits: A unified view of donors, a streamlined donation process, reliable recurring donations, enhanced donor segmentation, improved donation reporting, automated workflows, personalized communication, cost savings, improved form conversion rates, and improved financial reporting and compliance.
Challenge 8: Volunteer Management Limitations
Challenge: MGA was using their soon-to-be-deprecated proprietary system for volunteer recruitment, assignment, and communication for tournaments and events.
Solution: Leveraged Golf Genius League functionality for volunteer management.
Benefits: Consolidated volunteer management, enhanced volunteer experience, improved communication, recognition of volunteers, and reduced overhead.
Challenge 9: Complex Data Migration
Challenge: MGA needed to transition hundreds of thousands of records from their proprietary system to HubSpot while maintaining data integrity and relationships.
Solution: Comprehensive data audit, model development, and phased migration approach with extensive data cleaning and validation.
Benefits: The data migration resulted in successful transfer of historical data, improved data quality, increased data accessibility, cost savings, documented data architecture, staff training, established data processes, a future-proof technology foundation, a scalable platform, and enhanced data security and compliance.
Results and Impact
The transition to HubSpot has delivered transformative benefits for the Minnesota Golf Association:
-
Operational Efficiency: Consolidation of 5+ systems into a single platform reduced administrative overhead and eliminated redundant data entry.
-
Cost Reduction: Elimination of custom development costs and multiple platform subscriptions resulted in substantial cost savings.
-
Enhanced Member Experience: Improved communication, personalized engagement, and streamlined support processes have significantly enhanced member satisfaction.
-
Data-Driven Decision Making: Comprehensive reporting and analytics capabilities now inform strategic planning and program development.
-
Scalable Foundation: The HubSpot platform provides a flexible, future-proof foundation that can evolve with the organization's needs.
-
Staff Empowerment: Non-technical staff can now manage content, communications, and reporting independently, reducing bottlenecks and improving agility.
-
Donation Growth: Streamlined donation processes and enhanced donor communication have contributed to increased foundation support.
Future Opportunities
The Minnesota Golf Association is well-positioned to leverage additional HubSpot capabilities to further enhance their operations and member experience. They can implement automated email campaigns that target specific member segments. They are also able to develop a comprehensive knowledge base for member self-service. Enhanced utilization of HubSpot's reporting and analytics will aid in data-driven decision making. Additionally, they can implement additional tools with HubSpot’s suite to elevate member support, employ advanced segmentation strategies for hyper-personalized communication, and integrate with additional golf technology platforms.
Conclusion
The Minnesota Golf Association's successful migration to HubSpot demonstrates the transformative potential of consolidating disparate, outdated systems into an integrated platform. By addressing key challenges in website management, member data integration, email marketing, tournament operations, member support, course management, donation processing, volunteer coordination, and data migration, the MGA has established a technological foundation that enhances member experience while reducing costs and administrative burden.
This case study provides a blueprint for other Allied Golf Associations facing similar challenges with legacy systems and fragmented technology ecosystems. The HubSpot platform offers a comprehensive, golf-specific solution that addresses the unique needs of these organizations while providing flexibility for future growth and innovation.